Executive compensation discussions often focus on headline figures such as CEO pay levels, pay ratio disclosures or year-over-year compensation increases. Among America's highest-performing public companies, however, the more important question may be how executive compensation programs are designed to support business strategy, leadership continuity and shareholder outcomes.

Gallagher analyzed executive compensation practices across 250 top-performing public companies to examine how organizations that have delivered exceptional shareholder returns are approaching compensation philosophy, pay mix, incentive design, governance and disclosure practices. The findings provide insight into how leading organizations have refined executive compensation design to drive success in strategy execution and shareholder value creation.

Access the Full Report

How leading companies are aligning pay with performance

The highest-performing companies are simply not increasing executive compensation. They are continuing to place greater emphasis on compensation structures designed to support long-term value creation, shareholder alignment, and sustained business performance.

The findings highlight a continued emphasis on performance-based incentives and compensation structures that connect executive outcomes with long-term business results.

Three trends shaping executive compensation strategy

Three colleagues walk through their office space, engaged in a casual conversation that reflects a culture of openness and ongoing collaboration, highlighted by the modern and transparent design

Long-term incentives continue to take center stage

NEO LTI values increased 25.7% with an even greater shift with CEOs.

Performance-based equity remains the preferred vehicle

Performance-based equity is utilized by 81% of the organizations analyzed.

Shot of two businessmen shaking hands in an office. Two smiling businessmen shaking hands while standing in an office. Business people shaking hands, finishing up a meeting
Group of business people engaged in a lively discussion and brainstorming session. They work collaboratively, sharing ideas and smiling with enthusiasm. Shows professionalism and teamwork.; Shutterstock ID 2433610363; purchase_order:994005; job:EMEA + India (Europe MiddleEast Africa); client:Gallagher; other:Marcom: Stock Assets

Compensation communication continues to evolve

Transparency is increasing. Benchmarking transparency is not.

Questions every compensation committee should be asking

The strongest executive compensation programs are built around thoughtful design decisions, not simply market data. As organizations prepare for future compensation decisions, leaders should consider:

  • Has our pay mix evolved to support our long-term business strategy?
  • How much of executive compensation is tied directly to performance outcomes?
  • Are our long-term incentives driving retention and sustained value creation?
  • Do our incentive metrics reinforce the behaviors and results we most want to achieve?
  • How does our compensation philosophy compare to current leading practices?
  • Are we effectively communicating our compensation approach to stakeholders?
  • Where do our practices align, or differ, from top-performing companies?

What's inside the report?

The report includes:

  • Executive pay mix and compensation level trends
  • Long-term incentive design and emerging practices
  • Performance-based equity prevalence and vehicle analysis
  • Short-term incentive metric trends
  • Pay-for-performance alignment
  • Compensation philosophy and disclosure practices
  • Governance and board leadership developments
  • Industry-specific compensation insights
  • Practical considerations for boards and compensation committees

Executive compensation continues to evolve, but the organizations delivering the strongest shareholder outcomes share a common theme: compensation design is increasingly being used as a strategic tool to drive performance, reinforce accountability, support leadership continuity and create long-term value.

Gain access to the complete analysis of 250 top-performing companies and uncover the trends shaping executive compensation strategy, incentive design and long-term value creation.

Access the Full Report

Authors