An outdated rebuild value can create challenges for both the tenant and agents. When a building is underinsured against the rebuild cost, it can potentially impact insurance claim outcomes.
null

For resident management companies, freeholders and managing agents, building insurance is often renewed year after year using the same declared value. Yet construction costs, material prices, labour availability and repair costs may have changed significantly since that valuation was first established.

Industry guidance recommends that reinstatement or rebuild valuations are reviewed regularly, with a full reassessment undertaken at least every three years.

According to Steve Allen, insurance team leader, Gallagher, "Many people discover they're underinsured when they file a claim. The insurance company assesses the losses and applies the average clause, which proportionately lowers the payout. As a result, understanding the role of rebuild cost assessment is quite important."

What is a rebuild cost assessment (RCA)?

Unlike a market valuation, which reflects factors such as location and demand, a rebuild cost assessment (RCA) focuses on the cost of reconstructing the building for insurance purposes. This includes rebuilding works as well as associated costs such as professional fees, demolition and site clearance.

So, in short, RCA is the process of evaluating the cost of rebuilding a property from the ground up following a total loss.

For residential blocks, RCA provides a thorough basis for determining an appropriate sum insured and ensures insurance arrangements remain aligned with the property's actual rebuild exposure.

Which buildings require an RCA?

RCAs are relevant for a broad range of multi-occupancy residential properties, such as:

  • Converted houses containing several flats
  • Purpose-built apartment developments
  • Resident-managed buildings and larger residential complexes

The concept remains the same irrespective of property size: if a building is insured, its rebuild value needs to reflect current costs.

Regular reviews become even more important following major refurbishments, extensions or structural alterations, as all of these can impact rebuilding costs.

What is the difference between an RCA and an EWS1 form?

RCA and an EWS1 form address very different considerations.

EWS1 vs RCA
An EWS1 form is concerned with external wall systems and fire safety risk, particularly when cladding and insulation are involved. A valid EWS1 assessment does not establish whether a building's insurance value remains accurate. RCA is solely an insurance valuation process for establishing the rebuilding cost after a major loss. It does not assess life-safety risks.

While both may contribute to a broader understanding of a building's risk profile, they aren't interchangeable.

Who is responsible for arranging an RCA?

Depending on the ownership structure, the responsibility may sit with a freeholder, a resident management company, a right-to-manage company or a managing agent acting on their behalf.

Jenna Howe, sales team leader, Bournemouth Real Estate, Gallagher, says, "Many stakeholders are aware of the need for periodic reviews. There are situations where responsibility sits with volunteer directors or residents who may be less familiar with rebuild valuation requirements. In those cases, valuations can easily remain unchanged for longer than intended."

What information is required as part of the RCA process?

Usually, RCA specialist providers undertake a desktop assessment or a site survey, depending on the nature and value of the building. Property stakeholders don't carry out the detailed calculations themselves.

In the case of refurbishments, extensions, structural alterations or material improvements influencing rebuild costs, RCA specialists can discuss their suggestions directly with the property stakeholders.

When underinsurance became apparent after a claim

A residential property owner didn't commission a professional rebuild cost assessment to verify the building's declared rebuild value.
Following a claim, investigations revealed the property had been insured for only 67% of its actual rebuild cost. As a result, the policy's average condition was applied, and the claim settlement was reduced in proportion to the level of underinsurance.
The outcome left the property owner facing a significant financial shortfall since there was no accurate and up-to-date valuation.

When should you seek specialist advice?

You may consider engaging an RCA professional if:

  • The last assessment was done over three to five years ago
  • The building has gone through major works since the last assessment
  • Construction costs have changed materially since the previous valuation
  • The origin of the current rebuild value is unclear
  • Insurance renewal is approaching, and the declared value has not been independently verified

How can Gallagher help?

If you're responsible for a residential block and are unsure whether an RCA may be relevant to your building, our specialists can help you assess the information available, understand the requirements and explore the next steps.

Get in touch with one of our advisors on 0800 612 8631.


Disclaimer

The sole purpose of this article is to provide guidance on the issues covered. This article isn't intended to give legal advice and, accordingly, it should not be relied upon. It should not be regarded as a comprehensive statement of the law and/or market practice in this area. We make no claims as to the completeness or accuracy of the information contained herein or in the links which were live at the date of publication. You should not act upon (or should refrain from acting upon) information in this publication without first seeking specific legal and/or specialist advice. Arthur J. Gallagher Insurance Brokers Limited accepts no liability for any inaccuracy, omission or mistake in this publication, nor will we be responsible for any loss which may be suffered as a result of any person relying on the information contained herein.

Arthur J. Gallagher Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered Office: Spectrum Building, 55 Blythswood Street, Glasgow, G2 7AT. Registered in Scotland. Company Number: SC108909. www.ajg.com/uk